Even though I nearly always follow Mavis Gallant’s advice about reading short stories (in short, don’t rush), something about the way I’m reading stories this year has changed.
Or something about the rest of my reading has changed. Choosing more responsively has made my stack more unruly than usual. And some of the collections have a lot lot lot of shorter stories in them, which is also different.
Even though I have more story collections in my stack than usual, and though it feels as though I am reading from them every day, I haven’t been finishing many collections. So while I complete the spring quarterly, I thought I would share some of the single stories I’ve been reading.
All of these stories circle around the parent-child relationship, or guide/student relationship as in Heti’s scenario (with room to debate which fills which role). That was accidental, because I simply pulled six magazines randomly from the “neglected stack” but it felt predetermined. Five were from The New Yorker and one from The Walrus. (I tried to arrange five of them in such a way that, if you like, you could try to guess which is which, but the image editor is refusing to cooperate–apparently longing to keep all the fun to itself.)

My favourite all ‘round was Yoko Ogawa’s “Beauty Contest” (from the November 27, 2023 TNY issue) because it gave language and story, character and an element of surprise—in all the exact proportions which I was craving in that moment. In the opening paragraph, a velvet jewellery box makes a sound like a kitten yawning when it’s opened, and on the next page a hair oil smells like the beetles she collected for a school assignment one summer. Translated by Stephen Snyder.
Sheila Heti’s “According to Alice” (from the November 20, 2023 TNY issue) which is a construction based on the author’s communication with a customisable chatbot, over several months, the answers “threaded together” and edited for flow. (Discussed here.) It raises interesting questions about creativity and inheritance, about individuality and collective learning. Although at times I’ve enjoyed Heti’s curiosity, particularly her phrasing of questions and incorporation of answers from the world around her, I was craving more story than ideas that afternoon. (Here’s an interview which also discusses this work, via Lithub.)
Shuang Xuetao’s “Heart” (from the October 9, 2023 TNY issue) begins with a concrete scene but it takes a surprising turn as events unfold. This is one of those instances in which a single story from TNY made me go hunting for everything I could find by the author. (Which is a collection of three novellas, and a blurb that compares him to Murakami: Rouge Street.) But not because I liked it, simply because it was so unsettling and strange and, yet, relatble somehow. Translated by Jeremy Tiang. (Interview with author here.)
A more natural fit for my usual reading taste would be Sarah Braunstein’s “Abject Naturalism” (from the July 29, 2024 TNY issue) which is a realistic story about an older man who’s putting a telescope to the curb when a young girl passes. He says that she could make it work by ordering an inexpensive part online. She uses her mother’s credit card to order it ($4.99) online. Simple, eh? But no. It that leads to seemingly endless questions and suspicion, scrutinising how we trust and connect (and don’t). (Q&A here.)
Roddy Doyle’s “The Buggy” (from the June 24, 2024 issue) left me strangely unmoved on a first reading. When I returned to it for this post, I reread it, to see if I could locate where my interest flagged. It’s only three pages long (something you’d think I would’ve noticed) so I simply reread it and marvelled at its capacity to refer to such a complex backstory in just a few paragraphs and to create such a simple but effective resolution. I wonder how I missed it the first time.
Claire Cameron’s “Jude the Brave” (from the December 2023 issue of The Walrus” is probably the story that will stick with me, although I didn’t choose it as my favourite because there isn’t a lot of scope to play with the language and structure. Her syntax is simple, almost clinical, in an effort to avoid sentimentality because the theme (the death of a child) is so emotive on its own, and readers know where things are headed from the start. It’s about five pages long, and that’s how quickly she made me cry.
What else have you read by these authors? And what magazines have you been reading lately?
I have so many short story collections in the TBR, I never seem to get to them. I should probably do as you are and dip into them rather than think of reading a volumevall in one go. One of them is a Yoko Ogawa collection so you’ve inspired me to start there!
Your descriptions of Sheila Heti’s writing is exactly why I don’t like her writing LOL. It just feels like she’s asking a bunch of questions, and that annoys me. I like to read things that provoke thought, but i don’t like to read other people’s incessant questions. Just think of something you want to say and then write it down, anyone can think of a million questions!
And, yet…you never get tired of the whole “why did that person kill the other person?” question?! LOL
I’m kidding…I’m hooked on Scandi-noir crime these days myself…that’s a most excellent question.
Such an interesting post about your responses to these stories! Thanks for the heads-up about the Yoko Ogawa. I love her work, but this story must have slipped through the net at the time of publication. Definitely something I’d like to catch up with, especially given your comments about it!
First thing after I finished that story, I went to the library catalogue and saw that most of her books were on loan, which is a good sign in some ways (and lucky for me, as I’m too easily “and again”ing my way through 2025’s reading. Good potential there for a chronological reading project for me…except with translation that’s always a bit more complicated. Still…
Jude the Brave sounds extraordinarily good if an emotional punch in the gut. I’m a late convert to short stories. It was Lucia Berlin’s reisssued collections that tipped the balance for me.
The psychological thread that tugs beneath Claire Cameron’s fiction is what really makes her books resonate for me, and even though this is a short piece, you can spot it here, I think.
Ohhh, yes, I need to spend more time with her (I’ve read…two stories? maybe?); thanks for the reminder to return!
I read a few of Roddy Doyle’s books years ago and enjoyed them. But I’ve not tried any of these other authors. As for short stories, I read a few classic suspense stories this year by women in an anthology called Troubled Daughters, Twisted Wives. I didn’t finish the whole thing – I sort of tired of it – but the few I read were really good. I’d check it out again and read the last half another time.
I think I would need a longer time for a suspense anthology too. But that would be a great option for public transit reading!
I admire that you read so many short stories because they just aren’t my thing. If I am reading something short, I much prefer to read poetry. And sadly, I don’t subscribe to magazines anymore. I used to, but they have a tendency to pile up everywhere and I just can’t cope with that these days 🙂
It’s just a habit like any other, sometimes I lose it and then I have to remember why I enjoyed it and reestablish it.
Ohhhhhh, yes: The Piles. /gulpd But they have been working much better for me since I started to think as them as things to share, not like books on a shelf.
I read The Memory Police a year or two ago and thought it was great. I enjoy Japanese fiction, it always seems off centre to me as a reader of mostly Anglo lit.
TNY let me read According to Alice. Not my cup of tea. I am hoping to get through the remaining one or two decades of my life without employing chat bots.
Jude the Brave had elements of I’m going to make you cry, which annoys me, but then I’ve not had to live through anything like that.
I remember Wind-Up Bird Chronicle feeling like such a slap back when it was new, for just that reason. (I wonder how it would feel now, on the other side of 1Q84). Which was the short novel, or was it a story collection (surely not lol), you mentioned as a favourite Murakami?
Not one that I enjoyed either, but it also seems like an idea I’ve come across a few times in between: maybe it would have seemed more innovative if I read that issue when it arrived.
Hah! I get that. And I was not feeling predisposed to that storyline at the time either…but she got me anyway.