It was late when I picked up Emmanuel Mbolela’s memoir Refugee (2021), nearly time for bed; it occurred to me that another book might make more suitable bedtime reading. I’ll just start, I thought, because it was a borrowed copy and due back soon at the library. Straight away, however, he captured my attention in the history of Democratic Republic of the Congo. (The kind of ‘democratic’ that wears bunny-eared quotation marks. The kind that decimates bedtimes around the world.)
His narrative is exceptionally clear and direct; in short order, he fills any gaps in understanding that might exist for an historical understanding of the region. “The prerequisite for a true decolonialization of the mind is to take an active and differentiated approach to the history of individual African countries and regions. We need to understand that this history is very closely interlinked with the history of Western colonialism starting with the Atlantic slave trade from the early sixteenth century onward.” Immediately afterwards readers are engaged in his personal story, just as clear and direct.
By the third chapter, I was wholly engaged; I knew, based on the existence of this publication, that his escape was ultimately successful, but the intricacies and personal details made this narrative gripping and his style increased my investment while the difficulties he experienced in his journey intensified too.
Although a personal narrative, he frequently re-centres the narrative to focus on others who experienced different struggles: “Police raids and brutal arrests were the most frequent cause of suffering and death among migrant women at that time.” It’s a far-reaching story, and there’s nothing far-fetched about it: “No African dictator can remain in power for long without the support of the West.” (Translated by Charlotte Collins)
Patricia Robertson’s Hour of the Crab (also discussed in this season’s Short Story Quarterly) is her third collection of stories, which sports an impressive trio of blurbs from David Huebert (the writer whose horse story made me cry on the subway), Joan Thomas, and Wayne Grady.
Some of the stories fit with my climate change reading project, but the ones which really slapped me up the side of the head focus on migration. In “The Gate of Charity”, for instance, readers confront the tragedy up close:
“Ahmed, like Yunes, like hundreds of others, was keeping the fish and the seaweed company at the bottom of the Mediterranean.”
Robertson does not skirt the reality, the small percentage of survivors who leave their homelands in hope of surviving elsewhere, but even a statement like this one presents the situation as part of a broader landscape, not a story of just one man, but a universal truth which has created a legion of lives lost below the surface, with the fish and the seaweed.
Because we really are “all in this together” but not all of us are sinking yet.
In an interview with Scott Simon on NPR’s “Weekend Edition”, Valeria Luiselli speaks about how she paused her writing of Lost Children Archive (2019) to write “Tell Me How It Ends,” a “straightforward short essay nonfiction that’s a kind of X-ray of the American immigration system… of children arriving alone and undocumented at the border and seeking asylum”.
Afterwards, she was able to resume work on her novel with a new clarity: “It is not, in fact, a novel about the immigration crisis. It’s a novel that grapples with how to document and write about and think about political violence and about political crisis. It’s not a novel about immigration but a novel with immigration.” The novel begins, however, with the story of a marriage, against the backdrop of a journey and, because there are two children in the context of both, the story of the two children who have been lost in the process of crossing a border take on a peculiar weight and presence.
Like Alice Munro and Mavis Gallant, Luiselli’s handling and processing of absence is as significant as her story; I enjoyed following in her footsteps and I particularly appreciated the overarching conceit of how boxes and folders can both contain and obscure stories. “I suppose that documenting things—through the lens of a camera, on paper, or with a sound recording device—is really only a way of contributing one more layer, something like soot, to all the things already sedimented in a collective understanding of the world.”
It’s easy to draw connecting lines between Omar El Akkad’s first novel, American War (2017) and his follow-up: “With nowhere else to turn to, the refugees began to rally around the rain-damaged tents like antibodies to an infection.”
Even though I resisted the idea of it (partly cover illustration, partly misconceptions on my part), I was deeply affected by his debut; I still think about the characters in that story periodically—nearly five years later and a few hundred reads later.
What Strange Paradise (2021) is leaner, but I suspect these characters will stay with me too. He works with profound ideas—time and geography—but allows them to spiral against the backdrop of a young boy’s flight.
So a bus ride that normally takes 90 minutes takes more than a day; so on a boat ride, “the geography of movement was indistinguishable from the geography of stillness.” But his characters manage to express complex ideas in such simple terms and recognizable ideas that their perspectives burrow into your consciousness. Consider:
“The West you talk about doesn’t exist. It’s a fairy tale, a fantasy you sell yourself because the alternative is to admit that you’re the least important character in your own story. You invent an entire world because your conscience demands it, you invent good people and bad people and you draw a neat line between them because your simplistic morality demands it. But the two kinds of people in this world aren’t good and bad—they’re engines and fuel. Go head, change your identity, change your name, change your accent, pull the skin right off your bones, but in their eyes they will always be engines and you will always, always be fuel.”
Nanjala Nyabola’s Travelling While Black: Essays Inspired by a Life on the Move (2020) is voice-driven and I immediately felt comfortable with the balance of declaration and exploration; sometimes, her tone is very direct and knowing and, other times, she lays out complexities and seems to be navigating through them in real time. In general, she is reflecting on how, in one instance, she is perceived as a “harmless” “Western traveller overstaying their visa” and, in another instance, she is perceived as “a criminal who must be met with the full force of the law”.
The essays display experiences from both extremes and in-betweens and, along the way, consider debates that appear distinct but are united by their focus on the social construction of race and how that effects everyday lives. (The essays on Bessie Head and the potential and peril of Pan-Africanism really appealed to me, and following the thread of her Kenyan identity was particularly informative in how she perceives the nation and its colonial past and post-colonial developments.)
Her book “sits somewhere between the philosophical and the personal” and as such it will resonate most meaningfully with those who feel a personal connection to her tone and style but, even in the absence of that link, these are thought provoking topics.
“The experience of travelling while black—either as a voyager, as a migrant, or as a refugee—is united by this narrow thread of a soul rubbed raw from the disorientation of leaving what is familiar behind.”
I have just finished listening to What Strange Paradise which I thought was a compelling story completely undone by the last paragraph. Why would an author say Ha Ha, Tricked you, Everything I wrote before was bullsh*t. After spending 6 hours investing in his characters I wasn’t pleased to be told I had been wasting my time.
I think there are some clues during the novel that suggest he is presenting a composite tale and, in interview, he was questioned about whether he was writing a sort of fairy tale, an archetypal pursuit (fairy tale in the Perrault sense, not the Disneyfied versions) but I was still a little disoriented by the ending.
I’m not a fan of the nah-nah-nah-nah-boo-boo dreamscape-ending either (pffft, I can think of another recent novel that left me frustrated on that score–I can’t really say which one without releasing a massive spoiler, but I’m sure you won’t be heading in its direction anyway); El-Akkad’s didn’t quite strike me that way.
I know that feeling of starting something completely absorbing at midnight and coming up for air two hours later. And yet I am still sometimes the first one in the office!
It’s definitely a #niceproblemtohave isn’t it! And it’s a great idea to show up early anyhow…so that nobody notices if you sneak off to a quiet corner for a nap later.
Some incredible sounding books here. Refugee sounds very powerful and fascinating. I remember reading a lot about The Lost Children Archive a year or two ago, which put it on my radar.
It’s been an exceptionally rich reading year and I’ve been more grateful than ever to have access to the public library when I’m unable to purchase the hundreds and hundreds of books of interest. #librarylove
I’m taking note of these titles. I do have Valeria Luiselli’s Lost Children Archive on my shelves but just haven’t gotten to it. I think the more we can understand why people leave their homes the more compassion and understanding we can show. Just when I think of how the situation in the States can’t get any worse then we see the situation of the Haitian immigrants at the border. It’s just awful what has happened. And, just like it happens to them, desperate situations lead so many people away from their homes risking their lives for hoping for a better life.
I listen to an American news broadcast each week and thought the coverage of that was so interesting; it’s like they weren’t saying that it was unusual, for that kind of horrifying treatment, but that it was available for others to see was unusual. With that in mind, I think Luiselli’s story would reverberate even more powerfully for you in the southern U.S.
More great recommendations! I heard about the memoir somewhere else and have had it marked to read, so I’ll bump it up my list. I liked Luiselli’s “Tell Me How It Ends”, so it was interesting to hear about how it fitted in with the writing of her novel. I can see how that would work, how the nonfiction could bring clarity to the fiction. I’ll look out for that one too!
*takes a bow* Always glad to be a force of devastation and inspiration when it comes to the unwieldly nature of another reader’s TBR and the mention of other good stories.
Oh wow that’s a powerful quote you included from Omer’s new book – I really want to read it, but I remember being profoundly affected by his first novel so I think I have to prepare myself emotionally LOL
His first novel remains my favourite, but I admire what he accomplishes here, especially in relatively few pages (in comparison).
That quotation from Omar El Akkad knocked me out.
His debut, American War, is also very good. If you were tempted by him, I would suggest AW. Although this one has just been shortlisted for the #GillerPrize and it’s quite remarkable. Naomi has read both too, maybe she’ll weigh in… *peers into the distance*
Sorry I didn’t manage to join you for Lost Children Archive. The more I read about it, the more I think it won’t suit me as much as her nonfiction.
I love the look of Travelling While Black.
Oh, that was just timing, right? No worries. But, in hindsight, I agree, it strikes me that we would have had a similar situation as evolved with our Ali Smith reading, my raving and waving my hands excitedly and your pouring another cup of tea and petting the cat. ☕
On another note, I think you suggested I’d enjoy the new Violet Kupersmith (can’t remember if that was because you didn’t like it or because you did) and I absolutely LOVE it. (Just a few more pages to go!)
A cup of tea and petting the cat – what excellent ideas!
The Kupersmith is part of my review backlog at the moment. Given the ghostly themes, I was going to try to pick it up this month for R.I.P., but we’ll see if I get the time. I requested it on the strength of her short story collection, which I reviewed for BookBrowse. I probably recommended it to you in a comment on your post on Vietnam.
YAS! Why did WP allow the emoji for the teacup but not the cat? Committed dog-lovers?
Oh, yes, I think that was it! And it is fantastic for its sense of Saigon, that’s for sure. But I am mostly enjoying it for the checkerboard structure of time (it takes a lot of focus and is why I haven’t moved far in the Davidson novel yet) and for all the strange plot turns (not in spoilery ways, but in well-I-wasn’t-expecting-it-to-be-like-that ways).
When you post like this it’s always dangerous for my TBR! I like Luiselli very much though I have not gotten a chance to read Lost Children Archive yet. Thanks for the reminder. I will have to try and get to it soon.
Sorry? #notsorry It does take a bit of focus, especially as it goes on, but I think you’ll enjoy it.
That Robertson quote is definitely one of those that you read and stop and read again, and the El Akkad quote resonates too with his image of engines and fuel – or is it generals and cannon fodder?
I should probably clarify that while this passage’s clarity and power are remarkable (and encapsulates the nature of my reading project), the bulk of the book is very much story, which the NYT reviewer compared to a fairy tale (in tone) but the original fairy tales, not the Disney versions.
My goodness, these sound like powerful works. We travel for all sorts of reasons, but the refugees journey is the hardest – that quote from Robertson will stay with me…
It was one of those “stop and reread that sentence for a spell” moments for me. I find it interesting too, that these are not grim and heavy books, but each propulsive in its own way: perhaps, like their authors, always in motion.
The collection of essays by Nanjala Nyabola does sound intriguing, a writer new to me too. I have one of Bessie Head’s books on my shelf, When Rain Clouds Gather. Wonderful to get the inside view, thanks for highlighting her work.
Bessie Head also comes up fairly often in a podcast I’ve been enjoying a lot, with Marlon James and his agent Jake Morrissey, because James in particular has a habit of reading the authors that were read by his favourite authors, and Toni Morrison read and admired and recommended Bessie Head. (I discussed Maru here, if you’re curious.)
A fascinating selection of books again Buried. I have read one by Luiselli, and would love to read more.
I love your description of Nyabola’s book of essays as being voice-driven. I enjoy hearing different voices in writers, and this mix of “philosophical” and “personal” sounds perfect. That idea of “a soul rubbed raw from the disorientation of leaving what is familiar behind” – wow.
I’d like to read more of her work as well; Jacquiwine has recommended her essays and her earlier fiction also appeals to me.
There are quite a few of those little gems. Some might feel it’s too many, but I enjoy her blend.
What great and powerful books you have here. Travelling While Black is the one that immediately appeals most to me, especially as I’ve just read a whole book about Nigerian identity and could do with looking at people’s narratives from other countries now, too.
Another recent memoir in my stack might suit you too, Elizabeth Nyamayaro’s I Am a Girl from Africa; it’s immediately engaging and considers her experiences in Zimbabwe. Tsitsi Dangarembga’s novels would make a great follow-up to her memoir, too, if you haven’t already read them. And so on, and so on…heheh
I will look for that one, and yes, I have the first of the three by Dangarembga TBR
That will make another great reading project. *grins*