A couple weeks ago, I wrote about another long-term project I’ve enjoyed in 2024, slowly reading through the 584 pages of Ibram X. Kendi’s Stamped from the Beginning. Another book I started reading on New Year’s Day? Ruth Padel’s 52 Ways of Looking at a Poem.
Occasionally I forget a week, and then catch up. Actually, right now I can see my marker is stuck in week thirty and my calendar says we’re in week thirty-three! But that’s okay, because the project has served its purpose: I’ve already read as many collections this year as I read all through 2023.
I’m reminded that one can make one’s own relationship with poetry and it can work on its own terms. That doesn’t always mean I understand the relationship. Padel is a poet of no solutions: she exposes what’s there but stands back to allow you to make something of it.
She says, at one point: “You have to make up your own mind. Either the poem persuades you or it doesn’t. But first you have to go with, and try and understand, the flow and movement of its images.”
Elsewhere this year, I ran into this bit from Louise Glück: “There are always two people working on a poem, the writer and the reader.” Gluck landed in my stacks because of a novel: Jon Kalman Steffanson’s Your Absence is Darkness (which I discussed here briefly and also reviewed).
Ironically, when I added this book into my project list for this year, inspired by the idea that long-ago abandoned reading projects could be resumed and possibly completed on another go-‘round, I thought I’d left the project unfinished in an earlier year. But I learned, later, from notes made, that I did finish reading it a long time ago.
Did it simply not stick? Maybe I still lacked confidence. One of the many characters in JKS’s novel muses: “I wish I knew how to read poetry. I’m so stuck in prose.” Which is how I’ve felt for much of my life. Sometimes, I still feel that way.
Certainly the slant towards prose, which doesn’t feel as though I’m stuck…until I think about emerging from that swell of narrative. And there’s that deep-seated sense of not knowing, not understanding, which might be—as Padel suggests—simply a reluctance to “go with” it, to allow for a space where persuasion can occur (but, also, might not occur).
In Feeney’s How to Build a Boat (a novel which I fell hard into, many months ago, for its twinned voices, its acceptance of a quiet kind of chaos and determinedly quiet epiphanies) young Jamie reaches the limit with poetry. “Frustrating? Yes. Trying to figure out the feelings of the poet, and if he’s the speaker, and if they are the same person. And there are some clues, but no real answers Not really.”
But sometimes I feel like I see all the clues (as with Jo Gatford’s poems). I’ve also been really enjoying the ongoing project of reading the newest anthology in Biblioasis’ most-excellent series; I’ve just been on a hunt for Lisa Richter’s poems, thanks to “Whatever It Takes” which I’ve reread so many times now, that I’ve considered just memorizing it. So, on those other occasions, as with a recent reread of Ondaatje’s Handwriting, it becomes less pressing when I feel as though it’s all just flowing past me, beautiful and inscrutable.
So it turned out that my slow-reading project (my make-good-on-my-own-promises-to-myself project) was actually a reread. And it turns out that I could stand to reread some books annually, or pretty nearly so.
When you imagine looking back at 2024 from the end of December, what do you hope stands out in this reading year?
Is there a project or plan that you have been very successfully….ignoring?
I like this suggestion, “she wishes people treated poetry more like songs”. It speaks to my sense that, overall, poetry works best when listened to.
Like Jacqui I tend to avoid projects. I’m stressed enough about my reading – particularly the pile of review copies – without creating more stress. So, my only real project is always to reduce the review copies. I am often torn between those review copies I’d LIKE to read and the books I have bought that I really WANT to read. I am becoming a bit more relaxed about it all, though, since the pandemic. Well, really, since my parents’ deaths and downsizing, and my realisation that if people send me books without my asking for them, they have to take what they get.
Oh, and I do have the project of reading an anthology of Native American short stories. I have nearly finished that. The friend who gave me that has now given me one of Black American (or African American – I’ve forgotten the title) short stories. I plan to make that a little ongoing project, as I’ve greatly enjoyed the Native American one.
That’s true: I have fond memories of poetry read (between prose readings) at various events and they’ve really stuck with me over time.
For sure, if they’ve simply sent the book, without asking, any response is a gift. Even having dramatically reduced the number of ARCs or published copies I’ve agreed to accept, I still must periodically set myself to task to keep current (all queried, otherwise I would approach them moderately as you’ve described). I’m due for that shortly.
Right! That’s a great project, a single themed collection, and quite do-able, and I’ve enjoyed seeing which authors are included. It’s good that your friend sends collections at a staggered rate so you have enough time to anticipate and not so much time to grow anxious about the pile of short stories.
Yay for poetry! I’m currently reading a new translation of Rilke’s Sonnet to Orpheus and enjoying it very much. I always have one or two poetry books on the go and they are always slow reads because poetry should not be rushed.
My one and only reading project is to read all of Ursula Le Guin. It’s a multi-year project that I focus on in the cold months. It’s going pretty well 🙂
I haven’t gotten to the point where there’s always a collection (or two) in my stack, but i would like that very much. That’s more my pattern with short stories (I wouldn’t want to lose that, but I think I there’s room for more poetry, even so).
Do you have any of the MOdern Library editions? I’m curious how useful the supplementary essays in those might be. Have any of the books on the UKLG Prize List caught your eye for this year?
I sort of have slow reading forced on me. There are some books I can’t take with me when I go away – Laurence, The Diviners currently – and then I mostly read in the evening and only after I’ve checked out social media, so some books take a couple of months.
As for re-reading, and re-reading classics in particular, I have a houseful of books I’ve kept because I’ll definitely want to re-read them if not straight away then at least when I retire, but I don’t seem to be retiring.
When the bulk of my reading was done on my subway/streetcar commutes, that was true for me too: the biggest and heaviest books were read unevenly and intermittently at home, and weeks could pass with only a few chapters read. But, ironically, because I was NOT driving, whereas in your current situation, it’s because you ARE the driver.
Hah, nope, you do not seem to be retiring, that’s for sure. But the books are patient, and they’re keeping your shelves warm this winter.
I just heard Ada Limon on a podcast (First Edition) that she wishes people treated poetry more like songs – how different people can get different things from songs and there’s not this one certain way to interpret it, like many teachers have taught poetry (especially back in the “old days.:) That made a lot fo sense to me.
A project I’m ignoring? My Classics Club project! I stopped somewhere around 17 books to go out of 50. I feel like it was a project well worth my time for the duration that I did it, but I don’t feel the urgency anymore to cross items off from the list. I will probably get to a few more of them in time, but it’s not calling me like it was some years ago.
That’s a great idea; if we did think of poetry as songs, we would have entirely different expectations and attachments! Now it seems super obvious, doesn’t it!
At some point, I was quite happy not reading a classic for about ten years; then, I resumed fervently; since, I’ve only read one or two each year (if that); lately, I’ve been looking more in that direction. It’s interesting how our reading fluctuates over time. Had you originally chosen all 50 of the books, or simply resolved to read 50 classics, so there was wriggle room as time passed (like the wild cards in your Books of Summer challenge reading)?
So thank you for making me take another look at my list! Turns out I’d swapped in four books and have read two of those since, so I’m down to 14 books left. Not bad! It was a list of 50 I chose. If it was just any 50 classics, I definitely would have finished by now! I’m starting to feel that classics itch, though, so I feel like I’ll be reading one from my list before the end of the year.
Hah! What an awesome surprise, though, to find that you’d actually read some, while you weren’t aware of it. I don’t know about you, but once any reading list gets to under-10, I feel a fresh sense of purpose. I’ve got my reread of Middlemarch, and fresh reads of The Tin Drum and Catch-22 on my 2024 list, and I knew the two fresh reads would be in the fall, but…
I’m pretty sure there are many projects/plans that I have been successfully ignoring. But that’s okay, because the reason is only that I’ve been enjoying other things instead! So I can hardly complain. Although I probably do. Lol
I love the idea of books that are *supposed* to take you the full year to read. I don’t come across many of them, though. Maybe I’ll scout a few out for 2025 and choose one!
I like that quote from Gluck about poetry – I appreciate being reminded that the reader brings a lot to the poem. I don’t read a lot of poetry but when I do I feel like my experience of it is personal and not easily shared in a blog post. The poet that sticks out the most for me from this year is Margot Wheaton. Are you familiar with her?
If I don’t get goals for variety, I fall into the habit of binge-whatevering and that gets old fast but, by then, it’s too late, I’m stuck in a loop that’s hard to reset. Oh, I bet if you seach the ILL catalogue, you’ll find tonnes of options for 52 Thises and Thatses; I’m so curious now! I don’t recognise Wheaton’s name, but I’m rubbish at recalling the names of poets that I read in magazines and online; if you like her, I’m sure I would too. What should I look for?
I love this idea of reevaluating our projects, and promises to ourselves. I made an effort to read less this year, and try not to be so caught up in the ‘numbers’ of what I’m reading. I’ve been successful at this because I made a Goodreads goal of way less books than typical years, so I’m not feeling like I need to catch up with my reading (although the books keep flooding in from publishers, and I’m not trying not to let that bother me).
Why not share your intentions with the publishers; I’m sure they don’t want their shipments to make you feel guilty! I hope the comments I’ve been leaving on your site, about what seems to be working and not since your make-over (hee hee, can sites have makeovers?) haven’t been annoying; I know sometimes visitors see a different side of things and I find a fresh set of eyes helpful. At the same time, sometimes it’s overwhelming when too many things are going wrong and the reminders leave me feeling helpless. lol
No the comments are definitely helpful Marcie, keep them coming!!!
I tend to avoid committing to too many projects or group reads as so much of my reading is dictated by my mood at the time. Plus, there are always new books or reissues that catch my eye! That said, I am trying to read Anita Brookner’s novels in order, one every 6 months or so, and I’ve been doing that for the past 8 years. (I’ve jumped around a bit with William Trevor in the past, but he’s another author where that approach would make an interesting project.)
I loved your deep dives into various authors’ short stories in the past. Are you still doing some or those (or any plans to do so in the future)?
The new books still dominate my stacks too, it seems, even in a year when I’ve challegned myself to read more backlist and reissued titles. (I’d wanted to read 20 published in the 20th century and am just barely halfway.) I’m sure I’ve mentioned before how much I admire your Brookner project; she’s on my list of MustReadEverything authors, but I’ve done a poor job of it (partly because I no longer own all the copies that I once did).
That’s kind of you to say. This year Carol Shields, Jean Stafford and Nancy Hale are at the core of my story reading (Mel and Bookish Beck have joined in with the Shields stories) but I didn’t feel compelled to write about each story; I have a few options in mind (including Trevor, which we’ve chatted about before) but I want to finish the Audre Lorde essays first and, then, maybe. It’s a lot of work, though, and sometimes eclipses all the other posting.
I have my Reading Orwell project running this year and here it is August and I’ve only finished one of his books (although I have read a half dozen or so of his essays)! I seem to have taken the slow read of the bio about his wife (called Eileen by Sylvia Topp) too much to heart. I am thoroughly enjoying it but reading it a glacial speed. But I plan to finish it this month – 8 mnths is long enough for a bio 🙂
I have an update for the Orwell I’ve read this year, coming up before too long. That read rather quickly but I can relate to very sloooooow reading with a couple of other thick books in my stacks. It’s not too unusual for me to have a book underway for 6-8 months, depending on its size, but maybe not biographies…though books of letters, diaries, they aren’t far off, and I often take a long time with those.
The Padel book is one I’m really fond of – I read it after I left school and it opened up modern poetry for me. I have a lot to thank her for! It’s a great idea to do a week at a time (more or less!)
I like Rebecca’s idea of looking for her own poetry too: always room for another project…as you well know! heheh
I’m not convinced I’m a very good reader of poetry, but somehow I’m reading more of it anyway. Maybe I like being puzzled? I’ve been interested in the Padel.
As for projects, I decided this was the year I was going to read Gibbon’s Decline and Fall. I’m…making progress. 😉
That’s curious: there must be something about it that you’re craving, maybe as you say, a sense of mystery or possibility.
Oh, that’s a biggie. I would have a hard time with that for sure. Good luck! (Your comments were all in the folder-that-shall-not-be-named, rescued today: sorry!)
I’m glad you were able to rescue them. I don’t know why WordPress decided not to like me. Cleo over at Classical Carousel noticed they were being treated as spam after I wrote that, so I suspected that was what was happening everywhere.
Some service providers rotate IP addresses, after certain periods of time, which can flag your system in weird, unexpected ways (Rogers, for instance, if you deal with them) so maybe something like that, combined with leaving multiple comments on the same site in a single reading session (which I’m always doing, cuz I don’t have online reading time every day), that might have thrown a wrench into things? But who knows. I just hope it settles out for you.
Padel is an excellent guide to poetry. She has another book of this ilk called The Poem and the Journey: And Sixty Poems to Read Along the Way. And she’s a very good poet in her own right, one of my favourites. Should a review copy arrive as requested, I’ll be reading Margaret Atwood’s new and selected poems this autumn. At 600+ pages, it’ll be a slow read!
Oh, right, you did mention that: I must remember to track down a copy. Perhaps for next year’s reading!
THanks for reminding me: I had been hmming about ordering that but I’ve just taken the plunge. It’ll make a great (slow, yes, indeed) read for MARM.
“one can make one’s own relationship with poetry” – that’s exactly how I feel about it, my response is always so individual and personal. I think that’s what I love about poetry.
Ahhh, I was sure you were going to say something about ‘poetics’. /crestfallen