Sara Gruen’s Ape House
Bond Street Books, 2010
Reasons I read Water for Elephants:
1. I got tired of saying “No, I haven’t, yet”, when countless people — with all kinds of reading prefereces between them — asked me if I’d read it.
2. I love elephants (and books about elephants, too).
Reason I read Riding Lessons:
1. Water for Elephants was on my list of favourite reads for 2009.
Reasons I read Flying Changes:
1. I wanted to know how things turned out for Annemarie from Riding Lessons.
2. The horses mattered more than I thought they would.
Reasons I was desperate to read Ape House:
1. I freshly remembered how much I’d loved Water for Elephants.
2. And I loved the feeling that I had after finishing one of Sara Gruen’s novels
Reasons I’m glad I read Ape House:
1. Turns out I love bonobos as much as I love elephants.
2. I still have that same feeling after finishing one of her books.
But here’s the thing: when I take it down to nuts-and-bolts, I’m not sure that Sara Gruen’s writing is All That.
When I look at single paragraphs, I want to reshape them, tidy them.
When I look at chapters, I want to shift their emphasis and tighten and loosen them in spots.
But she reaches past my editing eye and pulls me into her stories by the heart.
Maybe it’s a cheap device, relying more on my having been raised with animal stories that entertained as often as they provoked massive bouts of weeping, than on crafting.
But I don’t see anything cheap in these stories, only authentic emotion.
And while some of the stories’ elements might have a formulaic feel to them, well, the fancier word for that is archetypal, isn’t it.
Sara Gruen’s narratives might not have the literary polish of Barbara Kingsolver or Alissa York, but her fiction takes on heavy and universal themes of belonging and justice, love and survival.
The emphasis is on story and character, and, when all is read and done, I’m also glad that she hasn’t burdened her prose with metaphors and polished her prose until you can feel its points.
Because I want everybody to read these stories. And I know that Michael Crummey’s Galore and Sherman Alexie’s Reservation Blues, are brilliant novels, but they are not novels that will appeal to every reader.
And I don’t simply want everyone to read Sara Gruen’s stories. I want them to love the stories in them too. And, then, visit her website and click on the Critters in Need tab, and marvel at the miraculous bits and try to rewrite the tragic parts.
Sara Gruen’s stories grab me by the heart.
Whose stories grab you by the heart?
Thanks for all the comments!
Jackie – If you loved Water for Elephants, I think you’ll enjoy this one.
Carrie – I’d forgotten about the movie: thanks for the reminder.
Kim – Yes, clean and functional: true. And nothing wrong with that.
Jodie – Thanks for the suggestion: it looks like a great reading companion! And I would urge a restart on WFE; I was afraid to continue reading it for the same reason, but the ending is something other than you would expect and somehow it mitigates some of the harder bits.
I like stories about apes too, so I’ll have to look out for this one. Since you love animals books I might just recommend ‘Captivity’ by Debbie Lee Wesselman, which is all about a chimpanzee sanctuary and human characetrs trying to keep it alive while working on their own relationships. Just lovely (although still sad).
I have Water for Elephants, but after I started it I had to flick to the end to see if the main characetr would survive – the tragedy starts so fast. Then I decided I just couldn’t stand sad right then, so back it went.
I didn’t read Water for Elephants for a long time, but really enjoyed it when my book club decided to read it. I agree with you on the writing — it’s clean and functional, but it’s not amazing. But something about the book just got to me. I’m glad this book does something similar, I’ll be looking for it.
I still haven’t gotten around to reading Water for Elephants (and I’m sure the “no, I haven’t yets” will pick up again once the movie is released, but I picked up a copy of Ape House at BEA and still haven’t read it. The subject matter sounds fascinating. I hope I get to it soon, and your review makes it sound perfect. I’ve been craving mysteries and stories to grab me more by the heart lately.
I loved Water for Elephants so am looking forward to reading this one when it is released in the UK. I am a big fan of emotional books so I’m sure I’ll love this, even if the writing isn’t outstanding. I don’t think it is cheap to be emotional and I’ll remember to have the tissues handy. Thanks for reviewing this one 🙂