Even though I should have known better, I started to read Miriam Toews’ new novel, Fight Night, shortly before bed and then stayed up to finish it. Because Shiv’s voice is irresistible and the story of life with her grandmother and her mother was so hilarious and moving. But I’ve been there, with Toews before, broken on the other side of her books. So I read the final pages of this novel almost straightaway. (This is a trick that I adopted at the end of my climate crisis reading, out of desperation and hope.) Even so, I enjoyed the ride.
Fight Night reminded me of Dede Crane’s Every Happy Family (2013), which I read as part of my backlist exploring, to write a review of her recent novel about Berthe Morisot. Crane divides her story into six parts, each taking the perspective of a different family member, so that readers temporarily inhabit each one’s experience and later follow the developments in their lives through other points-of-view. The last section is called “Chasing the Circle Closed” and she does a beautiful job of weaving the threads together in an ending that prioritizes credibility over comfort, yet still satisfies at a deeper level.
Also unusual structurally, is Carolyn Ferrell’s Dear Miss Metropolitan (2021). A story the narrators are telling “all from the perch of life lived, escaped, and lived all over again.” Having been imprisoned in Queens, their trauma was invisible to all who passed the building; afterwards, these women recount their story, with ample references to Prince lyrics, photographs (mostly the author’s artwork), musings on time and survival, and personal details from their experience. Sometimes lyrical (like an idea “as unripe as a banana still in its bunch” or a face “as sturdy as sandstone”), sometimes grim, sometimes inspiring.
With Leone Ross’ Popisho (2021) I expected a story like Ingrid Persaud’s Love after Love or Alecia McKenzie’s A Million Aunties. Instead, it’s more like Cherie Jones’ How the One-Armed Sister Sweeps Her House (for some darkness, gradual immersion in perspectives), Nalo Hopkinson’s fiction (the one about Jamaica for the island-ness of it all, but more so Midnight Robber, for the headspinny bits), and N.K. Jemisin’s Inheritance Trilogy (for the sensual collision of realism and mythology). What Ross does with language deepens the reading experience but, simultaneously, there are some very clear-eyed statements: “People is a complicated something. So is art.” There is one character here that I don’t think I’ll forget for a very long time. And there is one aspect of the story that shines with that kind of WellINever-ness too. It’s Hayley Wall’s illustration on the cover: it’s perfect.
Casey Plett’s A Safe Girl to Love (2014) contains the kind of stories in which someone gets felt up and it matters whether it’s over or under the sweater. She reflects a certain kind of coming-of-age energy that feels real and familiar—bars and roommates, shopping lists and tarot cards—even though not much of her experience overlaps with mine, which played out in smaller-venues with fewer-friends. But a lot of the characters are readers and the sense of being-in-flux is relatable. (My favourite bookish quote? “Nobody likes hearing you don’t care about a book they love.” I didn’t love Miranda July’s book either.) These are unapologetically awkward and tender, near-bruised and honest, and there’s even a Christmas story.
Lina Meruane Nervous System (2018; Trans. Megan McDowell, 2021) begins with an epigraph from Stephen Hawking on Richard Feynman: “A system has not just one history but every possible history.” This should have been my first clue that much of this book would sink into my eyeballs and stop short of comprehension before it reached the grey goo behind. And, yet, I responded to the overarching idea of this novel, that meaning is both very large, remote, and unknowable and—simultaneously—tangible, concrete, and gritty in our everyday lives. Divided into five parts (black holes, explosion, milky way, stardust, and gravity), Meruane uses these segments to explore different times. Across the narrative, they layer to pose unanswerable questions about systems of disease and decay, rejuvenation and recovery.
When I first heard about The Barbizon by Paulina Bren (2021), it reminded me of Sylvia Plath’s The Bell Jar, its young heroine lodging in a 1950s New York City hotel to work on a magazine. Turns out Plath fictionalized her personal experience in the Barbizon Club-Residence, but many other women writers also considered the Barbizon home. Bren’s style is casual, enthusiastic and lively. This “place where women went to reimagine themselves” has drawn the attention of other journalists, but Bren’s doggedness located previous occupants and there’s a hint of tell-all. Along with some lovely photographs. Despite the awareness that the hotel would eventually open to men (beyond the notorious cads who thwarted the front desk policies), then condominium-ed, there is an overarching sense of celebration: “The hotel set them free. It freed up their ambition, tapping into desires deemed off-limits elsewhere, but imaginable, realizable, doable, in the City of Dreams.”
It’s not surprising that Rafia Zakaria cites Kimberlé Crenshaw and Audre Lorde frequently in Against White Feminism (2021). That’s not the vibe I get; I’d look to Tressie McMillan Cottom’s Thick, Kim McLarin’s Womanish, Brittney Cooper’s Eloquent Rage instead. But I learned about Gita Sen, the Kally Bewah case in 1885, and a 1939 protest by Herrero women in Namibia. In about 200 pages, Zakaria illustrates the challenge of working “to relinquish the sense of being wronged” so that we can “work toward coming together.” Here, she defines whiteness as a “set of practices and ideas that have emerged from the bedrock of white supremacy”, from the “legacy of empire and slavery.” But it’s complicated: Zakaria prioritizes a view of feminism as resilience (over a white feminism of rebellion) and I can’t help but think of the podcast “Don’t Call Me Resilient” which challenges white feminism and the over-use of ‘resilience’. What each of us understands feminism to mean is different; reading books like this helps bring that reality into conversation.
Any of these in your stacks, now or ever? Do you have one to add? Or more?
I hope to read both the Toews and the Crane in the next week so it’s good to read your thoughts!
Crane’s Sympathy is another I really enjoyed. She’s definitely on my reading-radar now. Enjoy!
This post is a treasure trove of women’s stories! Vermette’s The Strangers would fit in nicely, I think.
I have just finished Fight Night and oh what a beautiful thing it is. And I knew what would happen very early on (by “knew” I mean felt very sure), so I didn’t need to peek. It makes me want to go back and read the ones I haven’t read yet – I think there are still three.
Casey Plett’s stories have been on my list since they came out. And then her book. And now her new story collection. Well, at least I have three to choose from now!
I don’t know any of the others. I love the cover of Popisho, but I’m not sure I understand what it is…
So that part where you felt you knew, that’s the part that made me read the final pages. (Which is a new thing for me.) What surprises me though is that it didn’t change my commitment to reading it and I knew even while reading it that I would happily reread it too. That thing. That’s the thing that makes Toews a marvel for me. I really don’t know how she does it. And I’m not even sure that I want to figure it out. I think I have three as well, but I think they’re the opposite of your three! *cue Carol-Bruneau-un-reading-project theme song*
Have you finished The Strangers? Or are you still reading? You just reminded me that Casey Plett’s new story collection hasn’t shown up for me at the library yet, and I know I was at the top of the list so I wonder what happened there (I checked, and they’ve not been received). Maybe those supply-chain issues are affecting Canadian publishers now too?
Yah, you won’t hear it from me. Heheh Popisho is a wonder best left undescribed. I do think you would enjoy it, especially one of the characters who’s a chef of sorts, but I suspect it’s not available in your library system, and it’s long, so as an ILL it might be a challenge (nearly 500 pages, I think?).
I’ve not read any of these but they all sound very tempting, especially Dear Miss Metropolitan. Generally I would never read the end of a book first but the exception is when there is an animal involved – I need to know they make it! So I definitely get the reasoning behind your new habit 🙂
Carolyn Ferrell’s short stories turned out to be brilliant and, given the nature of your year, I might suggest those instead, if you find her intriguing. The narrators in this one do survive their trauma, but it’s not easy.
Oh Against White Feminism piques my interest for sure. I sense reading a book like that would challenge me, and I need more of that in my life right now. Also, love the cover of Popisho! And I must admit, the thought of reading the last few pages of a book first makes me cringe, but I totally get why you do it with particular books!
It made me cringe, too, until very recently, when it became a necessary coping mechanism. It’s as though I only have a certain amount of strength to face uncertainty head-on, and if that’s spent confronting the climate crisis, sometimes Ima gonna hafta read the end of a book first (especially if that author has made me SOB with some other book *glares in MT’s direction*).
Lovely to see you covering The Barbizon here as I actually have a copy of it in my TBR (hooray!). I have a fondness for pretty much anything featuring a hotel, and its lively, slightly gossipy style sounds right up my street.
You’ll definitely enjoy that one! Of course it is non-fiction, but it reads so comfortably that I’m sure you’ll find its pages fly past.
Don’t know any of these, even the non-new ones. And Miriam Toews is the only author I’ve heard of. However, it sounds like an interesting bunch of books. Reading about women’s lives is one of my main interests.
Love some of the covers, and am particularly interested in Popisho.
Dede Crane being from an indie Canadian publisher, Lina Meruane being in translation, and Casey Plett from a small Brooklyn-based publisher that specializes in trans writing–I can see where these would be less recognizable books. But I think all the rest are from the Big Five, so it’s just another illustration of how much people can read and how there are always still more books and writers to “discover”. #niceproblemtohave
I think Toews is the only author here that I have heard of, and her novel does sound good. I also like the sound of Every Happy Family and Barbizon. Always impressed but just how many books you get through.
I feel sure you’d enjoy Toews, and it sounds like you’ll have a chance to read that one. Too bad that Dede Crane isn’t yet as available overseas, because she’d be your cuppa too. Well, I’ve got even more time to read, now that my TV viewing is further reduced–bah.
I have decided to start my comment by responding to this confession, BIP. ‘I didn’t love Miranda July’s book either.’ WHAT! I remember liking a bit, just a little bit. I don’t remember much about ‘The First Bad Man’. I read it five years ago. But what I vividly remember — it does make me cringe a bit now — is that I loved that Kubelko baby so much that I zen-doodled him. I can’t believe what sort of benevolent spirit possessed me then. 🙂 I haven’t returned to Miranda July’s book after that outing, and that suggests something about what I might have felt about the book.
‘Popisho’, which is called ‘This One Sky Day’ in the Indian subcontinent, is on my stack. It’s lodged in a dark corner in my bookshelf that I have almost forgotten purchasing a copy. I would like to read it soon. Maybe, this year? I lie a lot these days. Sigh!
Did you intend to play with words when you wrote the first line about Lina Meruane’s ‘Nervous Systems’? 🙂 The word ‘eyeballs’ instantly reminded me of her ‘Seeing Red’ which I almost read in one breath and felt compelled to bury the book or throw it into a moving vehicle for it to go so far away from me. Fortunately, I lent it to someone who hasn’t returned it yet; it’s been a couple of years. Thank Dog for small mercies! I can’t do that with my memory, can I? I haven’t forgotten the book at all. ‘Nervous System’ sounds enticing. The sections are named after everything I love. I am worried that it would be too layered for me to make my way through. I will add it to my list all the same.
I remember thinking one of her stories was just THE BEST. I think I read it online before it was published in a collection. But, then, I never felt the same connection with her other work, she doesn’t seem like someone you can like…you either have to LOVE her work (and I don’t) and want to zen-doodle her (this should be a GoodReads Shelf), or you’ve completely missed the point. Sigh. I feel LESS now. Just less. I wish I could type that in subscript, but WordPress won’t let me. Can we still be friends *hangs head*
KK, Popisho is a really long read, so I’m guessing probably not. But when you do get around to reading it, you will know exactly the THINGthatIamDYINGtoTALKtoSOMEONEabout. And I will not forget it. Even if I forget everything else about the book.
Yes, I was feeling a little playful (or, desperate?) when I was writing about Meruane’s book. It is the kind of narrative that makes me feel like I’m just not clever enough, like I can see the mechanical structures, and there is almost enough character to allow me to feel rooted in the story…but I never feel secure with it. It’s hilarious that you are relieved to not have had someone return her earlier book to you. Someone once loaned me Georges Perec’s A Void (the novel in which he never uses an ‘e’) and–I hope Kaggsy doesn’t read this comment because she will be offended on his behalf–it took me almost ten years to get up the nerve to read it and, by then, the book-loan-er said she didn’t want it back, so I realized that I’d been the recipient of the very kind of loan you’ve described!
Such an enticing list! I’m pleased to say that the Toews will be published here in the UK next year. Both the Crane and the Ross sound particularly appealing, too.
You’ve picked all the ones that I would have thought a great match for you! I think you’ll love the Toews. Even though you don’t normally reach for non-fiction, The Barbizon is exceptionally bookish cuz of all the writers who lived in the hotel, but perhaps better suited for the I-heart-VMCs crowd.